2019 Manager of the Year Ballots
| Voter | Lg | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brendan Kuty | AL | Boone | Baldelli | Melvin |
| Brian Golden | NL | Roberts | Snitker | Shildt |
| Bruce Levine | AL | Boone | Melvin | Baldelli |
| Bryce Miller | NL | Counsell | Shildt | Martinez |
| Chris Assenheimer | AL | Cash | Melvin | Boone |
| Chris Cotillo | AL | Baldelli | Boone | Cash |
| Chris Cwik | AL | Boone | Hinch | Baldelli |
| Coley Harvey | AL | Boone | Baldelli | Melvin |
| Cory McCartney | NL | Snitker | Shildt | Counsell |
| Daniel Brown | AL | Baldelli | Boone | Cash |
| Dave Campbell | AL | Baldelli | Francona | Boone |
| Dave Skretta | AL | Boone | Baldelli | Hinch |
| David Brown | AL | Baldelli | Boone | Cash |
| David Driver | NL | Snitker | Shildt | Counsell |
| Dick Scanlon | AL | Baldelli | Melvin | Cash |
| Drew Olson | NL | Counsell | Shildt | Snitker |
| Eugene McIntosh | NL | Roberts | Shildt | Snitker |
| Hal McCoy | NL | Shildt | Snitker | Counsell |
| Ian Browne | AL | Boone | Baldelli | Melvin |
| Ian Harrison | AL | Baldelli | Cash | Melvin |
| Jack Magruder | NL | Counsell | Shildt | Lovullo |
| Jamal Collier | NL | Counsell | Shildt | Martinez |
| Jeff Sanders | NL | Shildt | Counsell | Martinez |
| Jesse Rogers | NL | Counsell | Shildt | Martinez |
| Jesus Ortiz | AL | Baldelli | Boone | Cash |
| Jill Painter Lopez | AL | Boone | Baldelli | Hinch |
| Joe Frisaro | NL | Snitker | Shildt | Counsell |
| Joe Kay | NL | Shildt | Martinez | Snitker |
| Joe Ostermeier | NL | Shildt | Roberts | Snitker |
| John Shea | NL | Shildt | Counsell | Snitker |
| Jordan McPherson | NL | Counsell | Shildt | Snitker |
| Josh Dubow | NL | Counsell | Shildt | Roberts |
| Justin Toscano | NL | Shildt | Counsell | Snitker |
| Keegan Matheson | AL | Boone | Baldelli | Cash |
| Kyle Newman | NL | Shildt | Snitker | Martinez |
| Mandy Bell | AL | Baldelli | Boone | Cash |
| Manny Randhawa | NL | Counsell | Shildt | Roberts |
| Manolo Hernandez-Douen | AL | Boone | Baldelli | Melvin |
| Martin Fennelly | AL | Cash | Baldelli | Melvin |
| Matthew Leach | NL | Roberts | Snitker | Counsell |
| Nathalie Alonso | NL | Counsell | Shildt | Snitker |
| Noah Trister | AL | Baldelli | Cash | Boone |
| Pat Reusse | AL | Baldelli | Boone | Francona |
| Rich Dubroff | AL | Baldelli | Boone | Melvin |
| Richard Justice | AL | Boone | Baldelli | Hinch |
| Richard Morin | NL | Shildt | Snitker | Lovullo |
| Rob Maaddi | NL | Counsell | Shildt | Snitker |
| Rob Rains | NL | Shildt | Counsell | Snitker |
| Sam Miller | NL | Roberts | Counsell | Snitker |
| Scott Lauber | NL | Shildt | Counsell | Martinez |
| Stefan Stevenson | AL | Hinch | Baldelli | Boone |
| Stephen Hawkins | AL | Boone | Baldelli | Cash |
| Stephen Nesbitt | NL | Counsell | Snitker | Shildt |
| Steve Melewski | AL | Baldelli | Boone | Cash |
| Tim Booth | AL | Baldelli | Boone | Melvin |
| Tom Gage | AL | Cash | Baldelli | Melvin |
| Tom Verducci | NL | Counsell | Martinez | Shildt |
| Tomohiko Yasuoka | AL | Boone | Baldelli | Hinch |
| Vinnie Duber | AL | Boone | Cash | Melvin |
| Will Graves | NL | Counsell | Martinez | Snitker |